Earth Science

18. Observation, interpretation and evidence - understanding the difference

Jump to tasks
"If you haven't written it, you haven't done it."
David Lindsay, 1999, A Guide to Scientific Writing, Australia, Pearson Education

This remark is highly relevant to scientific writing. But how to write whatever "it" is can be a problem, since "it" can take many forms.

Observation: a bold statement
  • If you visit a plate boundary, you will find earthquakes; volcanoes; mountains; long, narrow rifts; folding; and faulting. There are three basic types of plate boundary: divergent boundaries; convergent boundaries; and transform-fault boundaries.
  • The creature had claws.
Interpretation: what the facts or events suggest
  • Plates cover the globe, so, unless our planet is expanding, to conserve Earth's surface area plates separating in one place must converge somewhere else.
  • The creature may have used the claws to climb trees.
Evidence:
  • Not all plates are major plates, for example, the tiny Juan de Fuca Plate, which is a piece of oceanic lithosphere trapped between the giant Pacific and North American plates; and the Anatolian Plate, which includes much of Turkey.
  • Fossils indicate that the creature had claws.

     
Acknowledgement: I have taken sentences and examples from Grotzinger et al., 2007, Understanding Earth, New York, W. H. Freeman and Company.


TaskTask TypeDifficulty
Task 1Multiple choiceMore Challenging
Task 2Multiple choiceMore Challenging
Task 3Multiple choiceEasier
Task 4Multiple choiceModerate
Task 5Multiple choiceModerate